quaker oracle

How Quaker Ministers Differ From Protestant Ministers

by | Sep 25, 2023 | Quakerism | 0 comments

A Quaker minister is someone in the Meeting who’s seen as having a special talent for ministry. How Quaker ministers look and what they do can be quite different between the various Quaker groups or yearly meetings.

Some Quaker Meetings are programmed and these look a lot like Protestant or evangelical services. You might find singing, a sermon, and the minister giving guidance to the congregation. These meetings are most like the original Quaker meetings from the early days of the movement.

Other Quaker Meetings are unprogrammed, which means, among other things, no minister. Congregants sit quiet waiting expectantly, and anyone who feels called may speak up with a message. Sometimes lots of messages get shared, sometimes none at all.

Then there’s some meetings that are semi-programmed. They often have singing, a sermon from a minister then a period of silent waiting.

Some Quaker Meetings are unprogrammed, meaning there is no minister. The congregation will sit in silent expectant waiting, and vocal ministry will be given by whomever feels called to. Sometimes many messages are delivered, and other times no messages will be offered.

Then there are some meetings which are semi-programmed. They often have singing, a sermon delivered by a minister, and then a period of silent expectant waiting.

For Quaker meetings that have a minister, there are a couple things that stand out:

  1. Recognition by the Community: In many Quaker meetings, ministers are not formally trained or ordained like in other Christian churches. Instead, an individual might feel a strong calling to minister, and over time, the local Quaker meeting may recognise this calling and formally record the person as a minister.
  2. No Clerical Hierarchy: Quaker beliefs say that all people can have a direct experience with the Divine without the need for an intermediary like a minister, priest, or other church official. While ministers may be recognised for their gift of vocal ministry, they are not considered spiritually superior or closer to God than other members.

It’s important to note that Quaker practices and beliefs can vary significantly depending on the region, the monthly or yearly meeting, and the local congregation.

Quaker Ministers vs. Protestant Ministers

Quakers and mainstream Protestant denominations share some common Christian roots but have evolved with different practices, beliefs, and structures. Consequently, the roles and characteristics of their ministers also differ.

Ordination:

  • Quaker Ministers: Historically, in most unprogrammed Quaker meetings, there isn’t a formal ordination process. Ministers emerge when individuals in the community recognize a particular person’s gift for ministry. Some Quaker groups, especially programmed ones, might have an ordination process. The leadership at Sūvata Friends Church are all ordained so we can perform legally recognised weddings and baptisms.
  • Protestant Ministers: In most Protestant denominations, ministers or pastors go through a formal ordination, which usually involves theological education, examinations, and often a period of candidacy or internship.

Educational Requirements:

  • Quaker Ministers: There isn’t typically a mandated theological educational requirement for ministers in unprogrammed Quaker traditions. In programmed traditions, there might be, but it’s often less strict than in many Protestant denominations. While many Quaker Meetings don’t require any education whatsoever, we strongly, strongly encourage all church leadership to be intellectually curious about the spiritual world.
  • Protestant Ministers: Most Protestant denominations require their ministers to obtain a degree from a seminary or theological institution before they can be appointed. Education of some kind should be required for someone who is leading a community of parishioners.

Role in Worship:

  • Quaker Ministers: In unprogrammed Quaker meetings, worship consists of silent waiting, with individuals speaking as they feel led by the Spirit. Even if a Quaker is recognized as a minister, they don’t lead the worship or deliver regular sermons in this context. In programmed meetings, however, there might be a pastor who plays a role more similar to Protestant ministers in sharing a message or leading the group through a program. In semi-programmed meetings like what we do at Sūvata Friends Church, the minister changes based on who feels called to give a reading. We do not believe that people are necessarily spiritually superior just because they speak in front of a room or even because they got ordained.
  • Protestant Ministers: In most Protestant churches, the minister or pastor plays the central role in leading worship, delivering sermons, and administering sacraments or ordinances. The minister is largely responsible for the spiritual formation of the parishioners.

Theological Authority:

  • Quaker Ministers: Quakers emphasise the priesthood of all believers. We believe that each individual has the ability to directly experience the Divine as we all have our Inner Bit of God. Even recognised ministers aren’t considered theological authorities over others.
  • Protestant Ministers: While the priesthood of all believers is also a concept in many Protestant traditions, ordained ministers often hold a distinct authority, and their interpretations of scripture and doctrine carry more weight than that of a lay person.

Pastoral Care:

  • Quaker Ministers: In the absence of a designated pastoral minister, care for members might be a communal responsibility, handled by committees or the entire meeting.
  • Protestant Ministers: Pastoral care—like counseling, visiting the sick, and guiding congregants—is a significant aspect of many Protestant ministers’ roles.

Variability:

  • Quaker Ministers: There’s significant diversity within Quakerism. For instance, Friends from programmed and semi-programmed traditions (like Sūvata Friends Church) might have ministers resembling Protestant pastors, while unprogrammed meetings might not have designated ministers at all.
  • Protestant Ministers: While there’s also a diversity of practices and beliefs within Protestantism, the role of the minister or pastor is often more consistently defined across various denominations.

It’s essential to note that Quaker practices and beliefs can vary significantly depending on the region, the particular branch or yearly meeting, and the local congregation. Don’t just assume that you know how a Quaker meeting is going to look without observing, asking, or attending. One thing we all do have in common is that we are welcoming and we want to have a dialogue with people who are exploring our faith.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *